Welcome to The Movement, tracking the influences and debates steering politics on the right.
The Movement
The Movement

By Emily Brooks   |   Thursday, November 19

By Emily Brooks

Thursday, November 19

© Greg Nash, The Hill

MAGA debates embracing American imperialism

President Trump’s capture of Venezuela’s Nicolas Maduro and his flirtation with using the military to capture Greenland has sparked an embrace within the MAGA movement of backing the U.S. as a global imperialist force.

But the revival of “Manifest Destiny” is brushing up against other factions on the political right that have preached foreign policy restraint and slashing spending, even on the U.S. military.

The faction that sees “America First” as a primarily non-interventionist sentiment — still burned by the failures in the Middle East — takes to heart America’s origin story as a republic that rebelled against an empire.

“I object to empire,” Megyn Kelly said on fellow conservative commentator Tucker Carlson’s podcast last week. “I much prefer the way we started with the original George Washington, let's avoid foreign entanglements. Let's not cozy up too  much to any one country. Let's enjoy the beautiful  blessing of the two huge oceans on either side. I don't want to have to take care of Venezuela.”

Carlson said he is "totally opposed to empire,” and preferred the idea of an “agrarian society with no electricity” — but acknowledged that there is a lot of support for a notion of an empire at the moment.

In a monologue, Carlson warned about the pitfalls of imperialism, and warned against not fixing domestic problems before tackling those overseas.

“If you can’t fix Baltimore, you don’t really have a shot of making Caracas functional,” Carlson said.

Both conservative commentators expressed alarm about Trump last week calling for a $1.5 trillion Pentagon budget to fund his "'Dream Military’ that we have long been entitled to” — a massive increase from the nearly $1 trillion military budget for this year. The Pentagon takes up the bulk of the entire federal government’s budget.

“That’s the kind of budget that a country that anticipates a global or regional war has for its military,” Carlson said. “That’s not a peacekeeping budget. It’s a war budget.”

Kelly said if the money was going to be used against the Ayatollah in Iran, “that’s alarming.”

The prospect of that major military spending increase is giving fiscal hawks heartburn, too.

Republicans have historically been huge supporters of increasing the military budget. But even some of them are surprised by the massive 50 percent increase Trump is calling for, particularly given the administration’s early focus on cost-cutting and the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE).

Republican lawmakers are publicly taking a “let’s-wait-and-see” approach to the Pentagon budget. 

“We certainly know the defense is one of our, one of our, one of the things we have to do in the Constitution, but we're waiting to see what the plan is and it needs to be paid for,” said Rep. Andy Harris (R-Md.), a key fiscal hawk and chair of the House Freedom Caucus.

Another GOP fiscal hawk said they would not accept Trump’s promise of using tariff revenue as a means to pay for the increase, particularly with uncertainty about the tariffs in the Supreme Court, and would not vote to increase the deficit. 

“I welcome that conversation, and I think, in fact, we probably do need defense resources, but we have too much unnecessary and wasteful spending that we ought to be bringing alongside of that to offset it,” said House Budget Committee Chairman Jodey Arrington (R-Texas).

Trump, for his part, told Fox News host Sean Hannity last week that the military already made “the best equipment in the world,” but more was needed because “there are some real threats out there.”

For now, those expressing alarm about the new embrace of American imperialism seem to be on the outskirts of the MAGA movement — with even former intervention skeptics backing his Venezuela and Greenland moves.

“How can you get more ‘America First’ than Manifest Destiny 2.0?” former Trump adviser and “War Room” host Steve Bannon told NBC News.

And that sentiment is certainly taking over the social media propaganda coming from the Trump administration.

“This is OUR Hemisphere, and President Trump will not allow our security to be threatened,” the State Department posted on X last week.

 

Welcome to The Movement, a new weekly newsletter looking at the influences and debates on the right in Washington. I'm Emily Brooks, House leadership reporter at The Hill. Tell me what’s on your radar: ebrooks@thehill.com.

Not already on the list? Subscribe here

 
 

HERITAGE FOUNDATION AFTERSHOCKS CONTINUE

 

Two more board members have reportedly resigned from the Heritage Foundation: Darryle Owens and Price Harding— businessmen who joined the board in 2023 and 2020, respectively.

Owens told National Review reporter Audrey Fahlberg in a statement that while he was not going to make any public statement about the departure — unlike two other board members who resigned in December — he wanted to clarify that he and Harding “each chose to resign” and were not asked to leave the board.

A Heritage spokesperson said of the resignations: “For some time, Heritage has been in the process of realigning the people within the institution to better orient ourselves to our mission and increase our impact. Changes in positions, from the board to staff, are a necessary part of this process. We are grateful to the trustees who have served and to those who will soon join us through a thoughtful process. Governance remains vital, and so does our commitment to lead. Our focus is clear: we are building an America where freedom, opportunity, prosperity, and civil society flourish.”

That makes five board members who have left Heritage since its president, Kevin Roberts, put out a video in late October defending Tucker Carlson’s interview with antisemetic commentator Nick Fuentes. That sparked mass internal and external pushback over not only that position, but over the think tank’s attempts to marry MAGA populism with traditional conservatism, upending the libertarian-conservative fusionism that had long dominated “Conservative, Inc.”

One controversial policy product emblematic of the ideological realignment at Heritage was released last week: A lengthy paper on family policy to encourage marriage and children. Many of the ideas in the paper — such as hefty tax credits for married parents, calls for a “uniform day of rest,” and grants for a marriage “bootcamp” to encourage cohabitating couples to tie the knot — raised eyebrows.

It was a long-anticipated paper. I wrote about a leaked executive summary for that paper back in September, with pushback from free-market types forecasting the schisms that dominated Heritage over the last several months.

Hours before the paper was published, the Washington Post scooped a draft of the paper from October that included a number of eye-popping ideas in an appendix that was later nixed: Giving parents an extra half-vote each per child; ending at-will divorce; having states pass laws to challenge Supreme Court precedents against teacher-led prayer; grant automatic property tax exemptions to families with five or more children. 

“As with any scholarly research endeavor, it should surprise no one that our experts hash out ideas and not everything makes the final cut, with some ideas adopted, others flagged for later development, and some dropped entirely,” a Heritage spokesperson said.

Meanwhile, former Vice President Pence’s think tank, Advancing American Freedom — which poached a dozen Heritage staffers just before Christmas, scooped up yet another ex-Heritage scholar: Hans von Spakovsky.

 
 

INTEREST RATE CAP: PUSHBACK & STRANGE BEDFELLOWS

 

President Trump’s call for a 10 percent cap on credit card interest rates for one year has made for some strange bedfellows with progressive Democrats and sparked pushback on the right.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) offered to work with Trump to push such legislation. Warren said in a statement that after she gave a speech Monday accusing Trump of driving up costs for families, Trump called her directly.

“I told him that Congress can pass legislation to cap credit card rates if he will actually fight for it,” Warren said.

Capping credit card interest rates has also been pitched by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.).

On the other end of the ideological spectrum, free-market economist Stephen Moore, a former adviser to Trump, criticized the idea.

“Price controls on credit cards NEVER work. Nixon and Carter tried, it was a disaster. Capping rates at 10% may sound popular, but it risks cutting access to credit for millions of Americans who rely on it for emergencies,” Moore said in a Monday post on X.

Conservative radio host Jesse Kelly said that an interest rate cap would not help with Trump on affordability messaging, and that the proposal would simply “regulate the poor out of access. As price controls always do.”

But Trump’s call for the policy isn’t the first that the idea of a credit card interest cap has circled among populist Republicans. Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) has also backed the idea, as has Rep. Anna Paulina Luna (R-Fla.).

 
 

ON MY CALENDAR

 
  • Tuesday, Jan. 13: The American Enterprise Institute hosts a book event on Niskanen Center Senior Vice President Brink Lindsey’s book The Permanent Problem, with its senior fellow Yuval Levin.
  • Wednesday, Jan. 14: The Bitcoin Policy Center hosts a private dinner with Sen. Cynthia Lummis (R-Wyo.) to celebrate its new office space.
  • Thursday, Jan. 15: The Leadership Institute hosts a training on “Rising to the Top in Washington, D.C.”
 
 

THREE MORE THINGS

 

1. Anti-abortion activists warn Trump

A coalition of nearly 80 leaders in anti-abortion activist space joined a coalition letter to President Trump and GOP Congressional leaders urging them to not be “flexible” on the Hyde Amendment and taxpayer funding of abortion, as Trump had pitched to House Republicans in the context of health care reforms last week. “Abandoning the most popular pro-life provision in history is a losing strategy, especially as we look toward the 2026 midterm elections,” it said. Led by John Mize, CEO of Americans United for Life, it was also signed by Marjorie Dannenfelser, president of Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America; Kristan Hawkins, president of Students for Life Action; Lila Rose, founder and president of Live Action; Terry Schilling, president of American Principles Project; and Tony Perkins, president of Family Research Council.

 

2. Tucker in the overflow

Tucker Carlson was present for a panel of oil industry executives at the White House on Friday, after reportedly having lunch with President Trump just before, per The Hill’s Julia Manchester, who was also in the room. His presence in Trump’s immediate orbit was a shock and disappointment to those who have aimed to cast Carlson, and anyone who associates with him, out of the conservative movement over his views on Israel and more. Laura Loomer, one of Carlson’s many haters on the right who has her own close relationship with the president, said she will tell Trump about Carlson supporting candidates running against those Trump supporters.

 

3. Back on air

Dan Bongino is restarting his show as a podcast Feb. 2. Since leaving his stint as FBI Deputy Director, he has started a crusade against “black-pillers,” infighting, and “anti-Trumpers” who “create division and drama.” That led to some prodding from former Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.), noting that Bongino never won an election. Bongino, in response, called Gaetz a “d---” and a “phony.”

 
 

WHAT I'M READING

 
  • Wall Street Journal’s Maggie Severns, Natalie Andrews, Josh Dawsey, and Eliza Collins: Washington’s New Lobbyists: Paid Online Influencers With Few Rules
  • The Atlantic’s Ashley Parker, Michael Scherer, and Nick Miroff: The Wrath of Stephen Miller
  • Tara Palmeri in Vanity Fair: The Hottest Spot for Sunday Church Is a MAGA Dive Bar in Washington DC
  • House Inhabit’s Jessica Reed Kraus Candace Owens Undone
  • Axios’s Alex Isenstadt: Bannon quietly making moves toward 2028 run
  • The Daily Signal’s Elizabeth Troutman Mitchell: ‘MESSAGE RECEIVED’: Inside the White House’s Reaction to Pro-Life Backlash After Trump Comment on Abortion
  • Ryan Neuhaus in Chronicles Magazine: America’s Affordability Crisis
  • Politico's Megan Messerly and Diana Nerozzi: Trump’s Washington is packed with Claremont fellows. That’s no accident.


Thanks for reading! Have some feedback? Tips?
Let me know what's on your mind: ebrooks@thehill.com 

 
The Hill on FacebookThe Hill on X - TwitterThe Hill on InstagramThe Hill on LinkedIn The Hill on YouTube

Privacy Policy   |   View in Browser    |   Manage Subscriptions
Sign Up for Other Newsletters   |   Unsubscribe 

 

400 N Capitol Street NW Suite 650, Washington, DC 20001
Copyright © 1998 - 2026 Nexstar Media Inc.   |   All Rights Reserved.